Free ↠ Reporting Pakistan By Meena Menon – Writerscompany.co.uk

Reporting Pakistan Meena Menon Was The Hindu S Correspondent In Islamabad Till She Was Expelled By The Pakistani Authorities In May In Spite Of Her Truncated Stay, And The Restrictions Placed On Her Movements, Menon Managed To Write On A Range Of Subjects Covering Swathes Of Life In Islamabad She Spoke To People From The Persecuted Ahmadi Community She Covered Protests Interviewed Victims Of Bomb Blasts She Spoke To Partition Survivors She Visited The Sprawling, Crowded Afghan Refugee Camp On The Outskirts Of The Capital Wrote About The Murree Brewery And Described Political Events, Including The High Treason Trial Of General Musharraf Reporting From Pakistan Is Considered One Of The Difficult If Exciting Assignments In Journalism, So For An Indian Despite The Limitations, She Has Produced A Probing, Incisive Portrait Of A Conflicted Society It Is Both Nuanced And Wide Ranging, And Tries To Look Not Just At Politics But Also At The Human Realities Beneath Reporting Pakistanis an admirable account of Meena Menon s experiences and observations in Islamabad as a foreign correspondent forThe Hinduin Pakistan Written with the grit and balance of good journalism, the book offers interesting insight about politics and daily life in Pakistan that were hithertho inaccessible to most Indians.Given the strained relationship and the stained history of the two countries, the life of an Indian journalist in Pakistan brings with it many challenges of acReporting Pakistanis an admirable account of Meena Menon s experiences and observations in Islamabad as a foreign correspondent forThe Hinduin Pakistan Written with the grit and balance of good journalism, the book offers interesting insight about politics and daily life in Pakistan that were hithertho inaccessible to most Indians.Given the strained relationship and the stained history of the two countries, the life of an Indian journalist in Pakistan brings with it many challenges of access, questioning, trailing and even suspicions of esponiage something that resulted in the non renewal of the author s visa and her sudden expulsion from the country after a mere 9 months However, there is also support, warmth and hospitality to be found amidst the citizens of the country, something that the author highlights and cherishes in equal measure The journalistic essays that compriseReporting Pakistantake one into her own experiences in the country, while also shedding light on important and diverse issues such as education, student politics or the regrettable lack thereof and refugee and minority crises aside from expected topics like terrorism, bilateral ties with India, and the issue of Balochistan I got to interact with Menon earlier this year when she was a lecturer at the journalism school I attend her writing here is as balanced, observant, analytical and funny as I found herself to be I recommend this book to anyone who is interested in journalism, Pakistan, Menon s work, or any permutations of the aforementioned this is a work of rare insight, both personal and objective at the same time, and one which you really shouldn t be missing Reporting Pakistan is Meena Menon s experience while being stationed in Pakistan for a period of nine months between 2013 and 2014 This book is structured like pure reportage, which makes it fairly tedious to read Menon gets across the problems and comforts of being an Indian, a woman, and a journalist with a visa limited to Islamabad in various sections Her reporting spans a diverse section from arts and culture to the fight for a free Balochistan and her experiences seem quite interesting.H Reporting Pakistan is Meena Menon s experience while being stationed in Pakistan for a period of nine months between 2013 and 2014 This book is structured like pure reportage, which makes it fairly tedious to read Menon gets across the problems and comforts of being an Indian, a woman, and a journalist with a visa limited to Islamabad in various sections Her reporting spans a diverse section from arts and culture to the fight for a free Balochistan and her experiences seem quite interesting.However, as stated previously, it is difficult to maintain interest in a book that isthan 350 pages, written purely in a report style glittered with few observations I also feel that people of Pakistan and India would be better able to understand the book because Menon doesn t focus on creating an overarching history she sums up basic plot points of a situation that is deeply fraught and intense She does make important points about how India Pakistan should repair their relationship and work towards a peaceful solution However, she is often asked why she refuses to report on Kashmir but she maintains her silence It is possible that the restrictions on her travel might have created issues of reporting However, if she was able to report on other stories, the silence seems somewhat uncharacteristic Her sanitised version of the conflict involving Kashmir also fails to grasp me If you re not into reading and aware of India Pakistan conflict, I d suggest to steer clear of this book Meena has done a great job She talks about Pakistan with impressive credentials Unlike Barkha Dutt who claims to be an expert on Pakistan, while knowing jack about that country, Meena really knows the pulse of this country What I loved about this book is that she is very balanced in her views She does put the Pakistani argument across also and let s the reader decide This is the sort of intellectual honesty that is missing in the narrative of many Indian journalists Meena has brought about Meena has done a great job She talks about Pakistan with impressive credentials Unlike Barkha Dutt who claims to be an expert on Pakistan, while knowing jack about that country, Meena really knows the pulse of this country What I loved about this book is that she is very balanced in her views She does put the Pakistani argument across also and let s the reader decide This is the sort of intellectual honesty that is missing in the narrative of many Indian journalists Meena has brought about the intricacies of living in Islamabad beautifully that both brings out the complexities of the nation as well as the qualities She balances the positives and the negatives quite beautifully The only gripe I have is that the book is slightly disjointed and feels like a collection of thoughts rather than have an organized theme

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *